The best questions to practice for XAT Exam are the actual XAT Question Papers. 2IIM offers you exactly that, in a student friendly format to take value from this. In XAT 2025 we saw some beautiful questions that laid emphasis on Learning ideas from basics and being able to comprehend more than remembering gazillion formulae and shortcuts. Original XAT Question paper is the best place to start off your XAT prep practice. This page provides exactly that. To check out about 1000 CAT Level questions with detailed video solutions for free, go here: CAT Question Bank
Read the following scenario and answer the THREE questions that
follow.
Mr. Zubin Mistry is the owner and the chief editor of the newspaper
The Pluralist, renowned for its high reporting standards and outstanding writing quality.
The Pluralist’s authentic reporting distinguishes it from other newspapers that
sensationalize news. They are responsible employers, known to be highly supportive towards
their employees. Its news editing team is led by Ms. Ramya Kattabomman, a respected veteran
in the newspaper reporting industry, well-known for her stringent adherence to the ethical
standards of newspaper reporting.
Mr. Aditya Swaroop Verma, an award-winning senior journalist, has brought in an exposé into
the activities of a mining company, operating in an ecologically vulnerable area. In his
hard-hitting reporting style, he has presented interviews with tens of people, delineating
how the mining company has used illegal means to start mining in that area. These mining
activities may lead to the destruction of the local ecological balance. However, Aditya
Swaroop is unable to obtain an interview with the management of the mining company.
Aditya Swaroop’s investigative report article offers significant revelations about the
alleged illegal activities of the mining company which were hardly covered in the media
otherwise. Nevertheless, his sources have requested for complete anonymity.
Question 14 :After the article is published next morning in The
Pluralist, it goes viral. However, the
mining company pushes back with a public declaration, contesting some of the findings of
the article. While the potential inaccuracies do not entirely invalidate the article,
they substantially undermine its message if proven true.
When Ramya asks Aditya Swaroop to bring in further proof to publish a rebuttal, he
informs her that his sources, for a vital part of the article, were two employees
recently fired by the mining company. And, they now admit that they were not completely
honest in their initial interaction with him. Though some points raised in the article
might still be valid, it is difficult to separate the inaccuracies given the
unreliability of the sources. Ramya immediately brings it to the attention of Zubin,
while admitting that she hastily permitted the publication of the
article.
What is the MOST responsible action should Zubin take, keeping in
view the recent developments due to the inaccuracies of the article?
Ramya and the newspaper did make a mistake by publishing the article in a haste and not completing their due diligence. It’s unfortunate that the sources were dishonest but the onus still rests on Aditya and Ramya as the leader of the editing team to ensure that they are publishing factually correct information. Hence it’s best for the newspaper to retract the entire article and Ramya to take ownership and issue an apology given that she leads the editing team.
A – This is unethical and would be completely irresponsible on part of Zubin given that his own team is at fault.
B – Aditya made a mistake by not doing his due diligence. Defending him in this situation is not a responsible action at all.
C – This may seem appealing, but the punishment does not fit the crime here. Yes, Aditya made a mistake. He should have conducted due diligence to be absolutely sure of the information. However, the core problem is that his sources lied to him. Hence, firing him in this situation is not justified.
E – This is highly unethical given the sources had always requested to be anonymous. The newspaper is also at fault and the most responsible action would be to take ownership of their mistake.
The question is " What is the MOST responsible action should Zubin take, keeping in view the recent developments due to the inaccuracies of the article? "
Choice D is the correct answer.
Copyrights © All Rights Reserved by 2IIM.com - A Fermat Education Initiative.
Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
CAT® (Common Admission Test) is a registered trademark of the Indian
Institutes of Management. This website is not endorsed or approved by IIMs.
2IIM Online CAT Coaching
A Fermat Education Initiative,
58/16, Indira Gandhi
Street,
Kaveri Rangan Nagar, Saligramam, Chennai 600 093
Mobile: (91) 99626 48484 / 94459
38484
WhatsApp: WhatsApp Now
Email: info@2iim.com